** The Rogue Cup Challenges **Updated July 18th, 2020

[Sol]

I'll take the other spot...unless a new player wants in.

Were you a lawyer before? I think you found a loophole in the game rules...

I was going to say that since you lost, you must skip a turn BUT...

- The Player that has discovered the lie becomes the Narrator for the next game. The other player must skip a turn before returning to the Challenges.

No mention of a Narrator losing...hmmm....


Player #2 it is, unless (as you have asked) a new member wants to jump in and give it a try.


Sometimes feel like a judge, jury, executioner with this thing...

I'm good with skipping this one.
Please give the second slot to someone else.

Well actually, I'm glad this came up. I will let it that Narrators that lose DO NOT have to skip a turn and here's why:

The Narrator's job is the one that is the most difficult. He has to really think to find two solid outrageous and / or outlandish claims. Then coming up with an outlandish lie, and upholding that lie throughout the game is not always simple. Finally, the odds are against him or her, no matter what, as 66% of the chances are that one of the Players will find the lie.

Yet, the Narrator only gets 5 points, same as a Player that loses.

For those reasons, I will add this addendum to the rules, in the official OP. Narrators DO NOT need to skip a turn when they lose BUT they are only eligible for the Player #2 spot, if available.

Sol.