Afghanistan: An Individual Soldier's Perspective Parts I - III - Printable Version +- Rogue-Nation3 (https://rogue-nation3.com) +-- Forum: Controversy and Debate (https://rogue-nation3.com/forum-19.html) +--- Forum: A Rogue's Opinion Piece... (https://rogue-nation3.com/forum-108.html) +--- Thread: Afghanistan: An Individual Soldier's Perspective Parts I - III (/thread-6386.html) |
Afghanistan: An Individual Soldier's Perspective Parts I - III - projectvxn - 09-14-2020 This thread originally appeared on Above Top Secret in August of 2013. Reposted here due to the addition of Part III. Parts I and II were written while I was deployed to combat in Afghanistan. Quote:And he is going to enforce what they tell him to enforce, and if a freedom fighter gets in the way.PART I Many of you know that I am currently deployed to Afghanistan. I want to share something with you that I went throughout here very recently, if for no other reason than to understand my perspective, irrespective of one's feelings on the political and social implications of the war. This isn't a commentary on that. It is simply my experience. If you wish to opine on the political issues of this war, be my guest. If you wish to rail against me, by all means, do so. But know this, until you've had to do what I have, don't pretend to understand, or be able to second guess my perspective on things. The quote above is from a former member, I remembered this post in particular because I've heard so much garbage like this on ATS before. This is sort of a response to that post. At the very least, you'll have my view of this on record: My second mission was a medevac chase mission. My helicopter is responsible for protecting the medevac bird from enemy action. The call came in and we rushed to the bird. We were up on comms and taking off on the mission when the details came in: "Patient is pediatric". I thought...OMG, they hit a kid? "Be advised patient is a 6-month-old infant." That's when my heart sank. I couldn't believe it. IED hit a civilian vehicle wounding this little girl to the point where she had damage to her face from shrapnel and had her leg severely damaged in the blast, which led to it being amputated. It was a remotely detonated device. Meaning someone had control of it and knew what they were doing. Probably using civilian casualties to try to draw ground guys into secondary devices, but that is speculation on my part. She survived. She could have easily died. The "Freedom fighters" are anything but. I don't expect anyone to agree with the war. Hell, there's hardly any support for the war to continue among troops themselves. No one wants to be in this crap hole country. But at the end of the day, the people we are fighting are NOT the good guys. They are NOT freedom fighters. They are murderers and terrorists and fucking child-killing monsters. They are tyrants who brutally subjugate women-denying them jobs, education, and any sense of self-worth. The post quoted above admonishes the notion of a soldier killing this enemy. The Taliban. I admonish the sentiment of the post entirely. I do not hold a reservation for them. I have no respect for them as a fighting force. They are without honor. Killing them would not disturb my sleep in the slightest. There you have it. My perspective as I understand it. From my own experience. Make of it what you will. RE: Afghanistan: An Individual Soldier's Perspective Parts I - III - projectvxn - 09-14-2020 Part II This part will focus on the Afghan National Army, heretofore referred to as the ANA. The ANA: Built in the aftermath of the US-led invasion, the Afghan National Army is a conglomeration of the several tribes that make up Afghanistan. Plagued by political corruption, tribal infighting, and insurgent infiltration, they have had a long, hard road thus far, and the road ahead is harder still. Every day these soldiers wake up in the morning, pray to Allah, and put on the uniform of Afghanistan to fight the resurgence of the Taliban and the foreign insurgents who help them. They do not have the assets we do. They know full well that when they go out and fight the Taliban that they may not be coming back. Their families are in danger. If they are wounded in action their golden hour is non-existent. So even if they suffer a survivable wound, they may not make it off the battlefield fast enough to stave off infection, or blood loss. They know this, and yet they still choose to take up the responsibility of protecting their nation from the slavery offered by the Taliban. The relationship between NATO forces and the ANA has been both beneficial and tumultuous. They have received excellent training and have been equipped reasonably well for a startup army. But sometimes the lack of understanding of cultural differences by NATO personnel has led to what is referred to as Green on Blue attacks, as well as unanswered grievances and infiltration by insurgents. By and large, our relationship with the ANA has been a good one. They have, for the most part, taken the leading role in the defense of Afghanistan over the last few years. While our generals and diplomats raise concern over their readiness to go it alone entirely, I believe, from watching these very capable patriots work, that they are far more ready than we give them credit for. They are keenly aware of what is at stake. They know the dangers, they know the benefits. I remain cautiously optimistic that the ANA, with all of its faults, can hold on to Afghanistan. They must, the choice to fail is simply not there. I have a lot of respect for these soldiers. They are the real heroes of Afghanistan and should be hailed as such. The sacrifices they make on behalf of their people despite the hurdles they face is something no other professional army in the world can lay claim to, to include our own. US-led NATO forces have sacrificed a lot here in Afghanistan. Lord knows I have lost good friends out here and I will always remember them. To me, if the ANA can stand and fight on their own, much of that sacrifice will have been worth it. But at the end of the day, we're going home. Afghanistan is not our country and we do not face the same dangers that the brave soldiers of the ANA do. I pray for the ANA. I wish them good luck. And may Allah stand with them in the fight for their nation, for they are the real freedom fighters of Afghanistan. RE: Afghanistan: An Individual Soldier's Perspective Parts I - III - projectvxn - 09-14-2020 PART III (9/11 Edition) 9/11 was a business opportunity and my friends and I were part of a protection racket with no purpose. I take pride in my military service for the personal changes inculcated through training and experiencing war first hand. But the war itself became an even bigger lie when we killed bin Laden and then stayed... The Afghanistan Papers revealed a lazy justification for continued operations in Afghanistan. A strategic black hole where otherwise intelligent military doctrine broke down into a toxic sludge of "pass the buck" leadership and profiteering. What we forgot about 9/11 is just how much power we handed these people back then who now endeavor to crush us today. Those innocent people were sacrificed on 9/11 for what Barack Obama would later call "a fundamental transformation of America" as he pretended to run against the policies of the Bush Administration. It was all a trap for us and 19 years later it is very obvious that we fell for it. We must never forget how easy it is to drag a peaceable people into war. Artificially prolonged war. Meaning that no real cause beyond the veneer of propaganda and lies from military leadership and presidential administration's going back 19 years is present. There's no depth here. No cause. We forgot how to be peaceful and since we have no real enemies we now turn the tools of the Post 9/11 American spy and war machine we created 19 years ago against one another. My how we have forgotten. RE: Afghanistan: An Individual Soldier's Perspective Parts I - III - drussell41 - 09-14-2020 (09-14-2020, 09:31 PM)projectvxn Wrote: The relationship between NATO forces and the ANA has been both beneficial and tumultuous. They have received excellent training and have been equipped reasonably well for a startup army. But sometimes the lack of understanding of cultural differences by NATO personnel has led to what is referred to as Green on Blue attacks, as well as unanswered grievances and infiltration by insurgents. By and large, our relationship with the ANA has been a good one. They have, for the most part, taken the leading role in the defense of Afghanistan over the last few years. It was the threat of Green on Blue that disturbed me the most when my husband was there in 2014-15. RE: Afghanistan: An Individual Soldier's Perspective Parts I - III - projectvxn - 09-14-2020 (09-14-2020, 09:46 PM)drussell41 Wrote:(09-14-2020, 09:31 PM)projectvxn Wrote: The relationship between NATO forces and the ANA has been both beneficial and tumultuous. They have received excellent training and have been equipped reasonably well for a startup army. But sometimes the lack of understanding of cultural differences by NATO personnel has led to what is referred to as Green on Blue attacks, as well as unanswered grievances and infiltration by insurgents. By and large, our relationship with the ANA has been a good one. They have, for the most part, taken the leading role in the defense of Afghanistan over the last few years. Indeed. We had a few while we were out there. One happened in FOB Apache. Immediately after the ANA and US personnel were segregated. RE: Afghanistan: An Individual Soldier's Perspective Parts I - III - projectvxn - 09-14-2020 I had completed so many missions with ANA special forces as well as their coalition partner forces (USSOF teams, SAS, Lithuanians, Australians, Italians, etc.) and had gained a lot of respect for them. I wrote PART II a few months after a firefight in Tarin Kowt we were in and the ANA soldiers there took the fight to the enemy and defended their base right alongside the Australian SF units I was there to support. I went on several air assault missions against the Taliban with ANA commandos who were every bit as professional as the SAS who trained them. Long story short, I got to know the ANA both their conventional forces stuck on guard duty the same as me and the special operators taking the fight to the enemy - coming out of the sky like dirty and tough as # valkyries. I understand now that my experiences with the ANA were not typical. Most ANA units are disjointed garbage units filled jihadists and undisciplined people. But the ones I was with were generally pretty solid. It is very clear how deeply my perspective has had to change over time for me to have gotten to this point. RE: Afghanistan: An Individual Soldier's Perspective Parts I - III - drussell41 - 09-14-2020 (09-14-2020, 09:50 PM)projectvxn Wrote: I went on several air assault missions against the Taliban with ANA commandos who were every bit as professional as the SAS who trained them. That's good hear, that some were outstanding. Frankly, I've always suspected your last sentence above. I don't respect the men of this nation, by and large. Between the way they treat their women and the bacha bazi scene.... ugh. "Women are for babies and boys are for fun." Yeah. I'm thinking fun might look more like dropping alot of them from altitude. RE: Afghanistan: An Individual Soldier's Perspective Parts I - III - 727Sky - 09-14-2020 Salute RE: Afghanistan: An Individual Soldier's Perspective Parts I - III - projectvxn - 09-15-2020 (09-14-2020, 10:16 PM)drussell41 Wrote:(09-14-2020, 09:50 PM)projectvxn Wrote: I went on several air assault missions against the Taliban with ANA commandos who were every bit as professional as the SAS who trained them. Efforts were made. Success was spotty. Thank the Aussies for the favor. RE: Afghanistan: An Individual Soldier's Perspective Parts I - III - Snarl - 09-15-2020 (09-14-2020, 11:57 PM)727Sky Wrote: Salute Raises glass. RE: Afghanistan: An Individual Soldier's Perspective Parts I - III - Wide-Eyes - 09-15-2020 @"projectvxn" I was hoping you would post these here. I don't really have anything to add but I'm interested in what went down over there and unlike ATS, you will get some solid conversation here and it won't just get lost in the archives. Thanks for sharing. RE: Afghanistan: An Individual Soldier's Perspective Parts I - III - 727Sky - 09-15-2020 Quote:Quote:Open Letter To The NFL PLAYERS. The Boycott is coming. RE: Afghanistan: An Individual Soldier's Perspective Parts I - III - drussell41 - 09-15-2020 (09-15-2020, 01:34 AM)projectvxn Wrote:(09-14-2020, 10:16 PM)drussell41 Wrote: That's good hear, that some were outstanding. Frankly, I've always suspected your last sentence above. I'm thankful that effort was made; even a few successes are better than zero. RE: Afghanistan: An Individual Soldier's Perspective Parts I - III - 727Sky - 09-15-2020 https://www.breitbart.com/sports/2020/09/14/nbcs-sunday-night-football-ratings-crash-nearly-30-for-woke-opening-weekend/ Quote:NBC’s Sunday Night Football Ratings Crash Nearly 30% for Woke Opening Weekend Not sure but it appears this is one war to change the hearts and minds of the football watching public that is not working.. RE: Afghanistan: An Individual Soldier's Perspective Parts I - III - F2d5thCav - 09-15-2020 @"projectvxn" Very well written, thank you for posting these. Cheers |